How to Pick the Perfect Fly Fishing Reel
If you’re new to fly fishing, there’s a moment—right between admiring that shiny wall of gear at the local fly shop and trying to make an actual purchase—when the panic sets in. You start wondering why something as simple as a reel feels more like building a satellite. But here’s the thing: choosing a fly reel isn’t rocket science, even if it kind of feels like it at first.
Let’s break it down, ditch the jargon, and get you set up with a reel that works, looks good, and most importantly—helps you catch fish.
What Does a Fly Reel Actually Do?
Fly reels aren’t just glorified line holders—though, yes, holding line is a big part of the job. They also balance your rod, provide drag to tire out fish, and make your whole setup feel like it was built to be together.
If your reel’s too heavy, your rod will feel awkward. If your drag’s junk, that trout’s going to laugh as it snaps your tippet and swims off. In short, the reel matters. But only as much as it needs to.
Step One: Match the Reel to Your Rod and Line
Here’s your first mission: match the reel to your fly rod and your fly line. Think of them as a team, and they all need to be on the same page. Most reels come rated for a range of line weights—like 5/6 or 7/8. That number needs to match your rod’s weight rating.
Fishing a 5-weight rod? Get a 5-weight reel.
Fishing a 7-weight rod? Get a 7-weight reel.
Easy.
What Happens If You Don’t Match Them?
It’s like putting a car tire on a mountain bike. Sure, it might “work,” but it’s going to feel wrong and handle like trash.
Step Two: Know Your Drag System
The drag system is your reel’s braking mechanism. When a fish bolts, drag puts the brakes on so your line doesn’t unravel like an old cassette tape.
The Two Main Drag Types:
1. Click-and-Pawl
Classic sound, nostalgic feel.
Best for small trout and lighter rods.
Simple, dependable—and very “A River Runs Through It.”
2. Disc Drag
Modern, smooth, powerful.
Ideal for bigger fish or strong runs.
Uses cork, carbon fiber, or synthetic materials.
If you’re just starting out and targeting trout, a click-and-pawl system is charming and enough. But if you dream of ripping streamers for browns or battling steelhead, a disc drag system is your friend.
Step Three: Arbor Size—It Matters More Than You Think
"Arbor" is just a fancy word for the center of the reel, and its size affects how fast you can reel in line.
The Three Arbor Types:
Standard Arbor: Classic. Holds less line. Slower retrieve.
Mid-Arbor: Middle ground. Good balance of retrieve speed and line capacity.
Large Arbor: Fast retrieve. Less coil memory. Most common on modern reels.
Want to pick up line quickly when that fish changes direction? Go large arbor. Fishing smaller creeks for brookies? Standard arbor will do fine.
Step Four: Consider Construction and Materials
Fly reels come in two main construction flavors: cast and machined.
Cast Reels:
Made by pouring molten metal into molds.
Cheaper.
Less durable. Can shatter if dropped.
Machined Reels:
Cut from a solid block of metal.
Lightweight, strong, and sleek.
More expensive—but often worth it.
If you’re on a budget or just starting, a quality cast reel is fine. But if you want something that’ll last longer than your waders, go machined.
Step Five: Left-Handed or Right-Handed Retrieve?
You need to decide which hand will crank the reel. This comes down to personal preference.
Right-hand retrieve: Hold the rod in your left, reel with your right.
Left-hand retrieve: Hold the rod in your right, reel with your left.
Most anglers reel with their non-dominant hand, but there are no rules. Just make sure you can switch the reel to your preferred side. Most modern reels are convertible—thankfully.
Step Seven: Think About the Environment
Where you fish plays a role in what kind of reel you need.
Freshwater: You’re usually safe with any decent reel. Maintenance is easy.
Saltwater: Salt is brutal. You’ll need corrosion-resistant materials and a sealed drag system.
Fishing saltwater with a cheap freshwater reel is like driving a convertible through a car wash with the top down. You’re asking for trouble.
Bonus Tip: Don’t Overthink It
At the end of the day, fly reels are important—but not that important. Especially for beginners. As long as you match your rod and line weight, have functional drag, and can retrieve without dropping the rod in the water, you’re golden.
Don’t get caught in the gear spiral. You’re buying a fishing tool, not auditioning for a Patagonia catalog.
FAQs
What size fly reel do I need?
Match the reel to your rod’s weight. A 5-weight rod needs a 5-weight reel.
What’s the difference between large arbor and standard arbor reels?
Large arbor reels retrieve line faster and reduce line memory. Standard arbors are slower but fine for small fish.
Do I need a sealed drag system?
Only if you’re fishing in saltwater or targeting large, strong fish.
Can I switch the retrieve direction on a fly reel?
Yes, most modern reels are easily convertible between left and right-hand retrieve.
Is it worth spending more on a machined reel?
Yes, if you want long-term durability. But beginners can start with a good cast reel.
What reel weight should I use for trout?
For small to medium trout, a 3 to 6-weight reel is ideal, depending on rod size and water conditions.
// Related Posts About Fly Fishing
